DOI: 10.1109/ISCIT.2019.8905238
Authors:
Boonsit Yimwadsana; Vichhaiy Serey; Snit Sanghlao
Abstract:
Location-based services (LBS) has emerged as a key computing application service for various industries as computing system is moving closer to real world human physical interaction. In the last ten years, global positioning system and object tracking have taken various industries by storm. Applications such as global positioning, navigation, logistics, object tracking, or even museum guide are developed around the LBS technology. The invention of the Global Positioning System (GPS) allows the method of trilateration to be used in full effect to pinpoint anyone’s location on Earth. However, the same technique cannot be used effectively when an individual is inside a building. A large portion of GPS signals from satellites cannot penetrate through walls and buildings. Various methods in all layers of conventional communication system have been introduced, and indoor positioning using Wi-Fi is leading the competition at the moment.This research aims to analyze the performance of Wi-Fi indoor positioning system in infrastructure mode. According to various studies and fundamental knowledge, the installation positions of the infrastructure access points to target detection areas of objects to be tracked pay the most significant role. In addition, bandwidth, types of Wi-Fi client devices, and number of devices in the area greatly affect the performance of the system. This work shows how these factors affect the positioning error the system. The results allow us to conclude that the current Wi-Fi indoor positioning system in the infrastructure mode can only be used in some applications that may not require extremely accurate positions such as navigation.
Rate this paper:
The paper titled “Performance Analysis of an AoA-based Wi-Fi Indoor Positioning System” by Boonsit Yimwadsana, Vichhaiy Serey, and Snit Sanghlao from Mahidol University, Thailand, presents a comprehensive study on the efficacy of Wi-Fi-based indoor positioning systems using Angle of Arrival (AoA) methodology. The paper is structured around several key components that make for a robust academic contribution:
1. Introduction and Background: The paper begins with a detailed explanation of the relevance and application of Location-based Services (LBS) in various industries. It provides a clear rationale for the study by highlighting the limitations of Global Positioning System (GPS) technologies indoors and the potential of Wi-Fi-based solutions.
2. Literature Review: The authors offer an extensive review of existing technologies and methodologies for indoor positioning, discussing the merits and demerits of infrastructure-based vs. client-based positioning, and various estimation techniques like Time of Arrival (ToA), Time Difference of Arrival (TDoA), and Fingerprinting. This section sets a solid foundation for their research by situating it within the context of existing scholarly work.
3. Methodology: The research methodology is detailed and replicable. The authors describe the experimental setup at Mahidol University, including the configuration of Wi-Fi access points and the parameters tested. The inclusion of input and output variables such as channel bandwidth, test points, device type, and positioning error offers a clear view of the experimental design.
4. Results and Discussion: The results are presented in a structured manner, with findings from various scenarios analyzed for their implications on Wi-Fi indoor positioning system (WIPS) performance. The discussion on the impact of channel bandwidth, device orientation, and the presence of interfering signals from other networks provides valuable insights into the practical challenges of implementing WIPS.
5. Conclusion: The paper concludes by summarizing the key findings, acknowledging the conditions under which WIPS performs optimally, and suggesting areas for future research. The acknowledgment of limitations and the need for further exploration demonstrate a scholarly approach to research.
6. References: The reference section is comprehensive, indicating a thorough engagement with existing literature in the field.
Evaluation
Overall, the paper is well-structured, with a clear flow from introduction through to conclusion. The methodology is robust, allowing for reproducibility of the study, which is a key criterion in scientific research. The analysis of results is thorough, with considerations of various factors that could affect the performance of WIPS. The paper makes a significant contribution to the field by providing a nuanced understanding of the challenges and potential of Wi-Fi-based indoor positioning systems.
The only potential areas for improvement might be in the depth of analysis regarding the algorithmic aspects of AoA estimation and a more detailed discussion on the scalability of the proposed system in different indoor environments. However, these aspects do not significantly detract from the overall quality and relevance of the paper.
In summary, the paper is a valuable addition to the field of indoor positioning systems, offering practical insights and a strong foundation for future research.
Rated score: 8.5/10 by ChatGPT 4.0